Unity on Wayland

Thursday, November 4th, 2010

The next major transition for Unity will be to deliver it on Wayland, the OpenGL-based display management system. We’d like to embrace Wayland early, as much of the work we’re doing on uTouch and other input systems will be relevant for Wayland and it’s an area we can make a useful contribution to the project.

We’re confident we’ll be able to retain the ability to run X applications in a compatibility mode, so this is not a transition that needs to reset the world of desktop free software. Nor is it a transition everyone needs to make at the same time: for the same reason we’ll keep investing in the 2D experience on Ubuntu despite also believing that Unity, with all its GL dependencies, is the best interface for the desktop. We’ll help GNOME and KDE with the transition, there’s no reason for them not to be there on day one either.

Timeframes are difficult. I’m sure we could deliver *something* in six months, but I think a year is more realistic for the first images that will be widely useful in our community. I’d love to be proven conservative on that :-) but I suspect it’s more likely to err the other way. It might take four or more years to really move the ecosystem. Progress on Wayland itself is sufficient for me to be confident that no other initiative could outrun it, especially if we deliver things like Unity and uTouch with it. And also if we make an early public statement in support of the project. Which this is!

In coming to this view, several scenarios were considered.

One is the continued improvement of X, which is a more vibrant project these days than it once was. X will be around a long time, hence the importance of our confidence levels on the idea of a compatibility environment. But we don’t believe X is setup to deliver the user experience we want, with super-smooth graphics and effects. I understand that it’s *possible* to get amazing results with X, but it’s extremely hard, and isn’t going to get easier. Some of the core goals of X make it harder to achieve these user experiences on X than on native GL, we’re choosing to prioritize the quality of experience over those original values, like network transparency.

We considered the Android compositing environment. It’s great for Android, but we felt it would be more difficult to bring the whole free software stack along with us if we pursued that direction.

We considered and spoke with several proprietary options, on the basis that they might be persuaded to open source their work for a new push, and we evaluated the cost of building a new display manager, informed by the lessons learned in Wayland. We came to the conclusion that any such effort would only create a hard split in the world which wasn’t worth the cost of having done it. There are issues with Wayland, but they seem to be solvable, we’d rather be part of solving them than chasing a better alternative. So Wayland it is.

In general, this will all be fine – actually *great* – for folks who have good open source drivers for their graphics hardware. Wayland depends on things they are all moving to support: kernel modesetting, gem buffers and so on. The requirement of EGL is new but consistent with industry standards from Khronos – both GLES and GL will be supported. We’d like to hear from vendors for whom this would be problematic, but hope it provides yet another (and perhaps definitive) motive to move to open source drivers for all Linux work.

307 Responses to “Unity on Wayland”

  1. jo Says:

    What about the cloud and remote desktop to it? There is nothing that beats NX at the moment. Will it still work?

  2. Ubuntu przyjmie Wayland graficzne System | proportional Says:

    […] zamiast Wayland, chude, OpenGL system zarządzania wyświetlacz, Mark Shuttleworth powiedział w post czwartek na swoim […]

  3. PC Blog » Blog Archive » Ubuntu жертвует традициями Linux в пользу удобства пользователей Says:

    […] проекта Ubuntu Марк Шаттлворт (Mark Shuttleworth) в своем блоге сообщил, что команда Ubuntu не остановится и на этом. […]

  4. Дорога к Wayland: готовимся к жизни «после X» | My BLOG Says:

    […] важное, например, X на Wayland, что может произойти в Ubuntu по предложению Марка Шаттлворта. Реакция на пост Марк Шаттлворта, а […]

  5. Ubuntu to drop X Server for Wayland | Says:

    […] I didn’t see this coming: Mark Shuttleworth, founder of Ubuntu backer Canonical, has announced that somewhere down the road, Ubuntu will be switching Ubuntu’s base graphics system from the venerable X Windows System to …. […]

  6. gadgetboi Says:

    If it is good, why not? :mrgreen:

    i havent tried unity yet, still stay with lucid. 3 years baby! 😆 yay! Why bother … I’ll wait the 13.04 instead 😀

  7. Imran Chaudhry Says:

    Thanks for posting Mark. I wish you, and the whole Ubuntu team, the best for this push to Unity and Wayland. It is very exciting stuff and I look forward to all this goodness in a stable form on Ubuntu 12.04!